Corporate bonds look better, long-term Treasuries less so
Corporate bond yields have risen faster than Treasury yields, so corporate bonds now pay clearly more. Long-term Treasuries, meanwhile, pay barely more than medium-term ones. So expected returns rose for HYG and LQD and fell for IEF and TLT.
What changed
| Symbol | Before | After | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| iShares iBoxx $ High Yield Corporate Bond ETFHYG | 5.13% | 5.42% | +0.29pp |
| iShares iBoxx $ Investment Grade Corporate Bond ETFLQD | 5.87% | 5.97% | +0.10pp |
| iShares 7-10 Year Treasury Bond ETFIEF | 5.76% | 5.53% | −0.23pp |
| TLT | 6.51% | 6.24% | −0.27pp |
Figures are annual expected returns (arithmetic means), after fees for funds. They are not a forecast or a promise.
Corporate bond yields rose faster than Treasury yields
On October 1, high-yield corporate bonds yielded 8.22% a year, up more than a point from 7.18% a month earlier. Their gap over Treasuries widened from 2.65 to 3.24 points over the same month. Investment-grade corporate bonds, from highly rated companies, yield 5.99%, more than Treasuries of similar maturity.
A bond's future is best told by the interest it pays today
Held to maturity, a bond pays the interest fixed when it was bought. So today's yield is the best starting point for judging a bond's future return. High-yield bonds lose something to the companies that default, but even after allowing for that, today's yield is high.
Long-term Treasuries are not paid for the wait
Treasuries of 20 years and more yield 5.62%, only a little above the 5.17% of 7- to 10-year Treasuries, and 20- and 30-year yields are almost the same. Long-term Treasuries swing far more when interest rates move, and they are paid little extra for it.
The chart below lays a year of simulated outcomes for the long-term fund TLT over the medium-term fund IEF. TLT's expected return (6.24%) is higher than IEF's (5.53%), but its price swings are more than twice as large, so the most typical outcome, the median, is about the same for both, around 5.3%. TLT's range of outcomes is far wider: the same typical result, for a much bumpier ride.
TLT, one year simulated
So bond funds' expected returns changed like this
The high-yield fund HYG's expected return rose from 5.13% to 5.42%, and the investment-grade fund LQD's from 5.87% to 5.97%. The medium-term Treasury fund IEF fell from 5.76% to 5.53%, and the long-term Treasury fund TLT from 6.51% to 6.24%. Expected returns on stocks did not change.
What to watch
Part of the rise in high-yield yields is worry that more companies will default. The gap over Treasuries for the lowest-rated companies is above 12 points, the highest in three years. If that worry comes true, the higher interest may not make up for the losses, so these changes are smaller than the yield gaps alone suggest. We will look at corporate bond yields again by the end of November.