The safe interest rate rose, and every expected return rose with it
The 10-year US Treasury yield, the return you can get with almost no risk, rose from 4.76% to 5.24% in a month. Every investment has to beat it, so expected returns rose by the same 0.48 points: the S&P 500 from 8.52% to 9.00%.
What changed
| Symbol | Before | After | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| The S&P 500SPY | 8.52% | 9.00% | +0.48pp |
| The Nasdaq 100QQQ | 9.78% | 10.26% | +0.48pp |
| AppleAAPL | 5.77% | 6.25% | +0.48pp |
| NvidiaNVDA | 18.93% | 19.41% | +0.48pp |
| Samsung Electronics005930 | 12.67% | 13.15% | +0.48pp |
| TLT | 6.03% | 6.51% | +0.48pp |
| GLD | 5.22% | 5.70% | +0.48pp |
| iShares 1-3 Year Treasury Bond ETFSHY | 4.72% | 5.20% | +0.48pp |
This change moved 639 symbols; the table shows a few. Figures are annual expected returns (arithmetic means), after fees for funds. They are not a forecast or a promise.
The safe rate went up
When you lend money to the US government for ten years, by buying a 10-year Treasury bond, you earn a yield with almost no risk of not being paid back. On October 1 that yield closed at 5.24%. In early September it was 4.76%, so it rose by nearly half a point in a month, to its highest level since 2002.
The rise did not come from fears of higher prices. The inflation investors expect stayed at about 2.4% a year. What rose was the yield after inflation, to 2.88%: investors now ask to be paid more for tying up their money for a long time.
Why every investment starts from it
Every investment competes with that safe yield. If the government pays 5.24% with almost no risk, nobody would hold a riskier investment, a stock or a corporate bond, unless they expected more than 5.24% from it. So any expected return can be read as two parts: the safe yield, plus an extra reward for taking risk.
The ten-year yield is the one to use because most of these investments are held for years, so they compete with a safe investment of similar length.
So expected returns rose by the same amount
The safe yield rose by 0.48 points, and nothing suggested that investors now want a bigger or smaller reward for risk. So the first part rose and the second stayed the same: expected returns on stocks, bonds and commodities all rose by the same 0.48 points. The S&P 500's expected return went from 8.52% to 9.00%, and the Nasdaq 100's from 9.78% to 10.26%. 639 of the 642 investments here moved this way. Only three funds whose returns are set in a different way, such as the volatility fund VXX, did not.
The chart lays a year of simulated outcomes for the S&P 500 over the same simulation before the change. The two ranges almost cover each other: half a point is small next to how far stocks can move in a year, so the middle shifts a little and the range stays the same.
SPY, one year simulated
Which investments look better did not change
Because everything moved by the same amount, no investment looks better or worse against another than it did before. What moved is the starting line. When a safe bond pays more, a riskier investment has to earn more than that to be worth holding.